FiDi First Date Ideas

Q: FiDi first date vibes

Some unexpectedly great date nights have occured in Fidi - the bars are generally less crowded, have some historic charm and plenty of nooks and crannies to slip into. Plus, all the spots are super close together - so no long walks in between destinations. If she lives down here, you can score bonus points by planning something in her hood.

Q: How much will this neighborhood set me back?

For a casual night: Start at Dead Rabbit ($50-70) → Stone Street Tavern for bites ($70-90) → Ulysses if you keep going ($40-60). Expect around $160-220 total for a full casual date night. For a fancier vibe: The Bedford dinner ($100-150) → Fraunces Tavern for drinks ($60-90) runs you about $160-240. Bottom line—FiDi has solid options at every price point, and the close proximity means you're not committing to one expensive spot all night.

The redcoats invaded Manhattan, turning it into an imperial stronghold and forcing a battered Continental Army into retreat and making the city a symbol of imperial control. Years later, George Washington returned in triumph, riding back into Manhattan as the British evacuated (eagles screeching). If Washington can save victory from the jaws of defeat, you can plan a great night in FiDi.

Date spots to know

Dead Rabbit — top 5 Guiness pint in the city, also great cocktails
Stone Street Tavern — the mature place to grab post-pub bites
Ulysses — large bar, good food, great spot to do a little of both
The Bedford — they have their own proprietary hot toddy w/ honey crisp apple church, chamomile and lemon + any alcohol you want
Fraunces Tavern — nooks and crannies abound at this historic pub. The whiskey bar is cozy, and the piano bar upstairs sets the right mood.

Be wary soldier, it's a first date

Casual first drink 🍸

★★★★ nanci brillant

"Definitely an iconic place and super busy no matter when you go. The food was good. Our party ordered multiple different..."

Dead Rabbit: Website

Address: 30 Water St

Happy Hour: 4-6pm Mon-Fri

Expected Check: $50-70 (2 drinks each)

Reservations: Recommended - Resy

Move to light bites? 🥟

★★★★★ Marcus Hilka

"Stone Street is one of those hidden gems in New York City that feels like you’ve stepped into another world. Tucked away..."

Stone Street Tavern: Website

Address: 52 Stone St

Happy Hour: 4-7pm Mon-Fri

Expected Check: $70-90 (1 drink/pp + apps)

Reservations: Recommended - OpenTable

Ditch 'n Drink 🍺

★★★★★ Mahima Srivastava

"Been a regular at Ulysses before pandemic and came back again for their Monday Lobster special. Can't beat the $26 Lobst..."

Ulysses: Website

Address: 58 Stone St

Happy Hour: Daily 4-8pm

Expected Check: $40-60 (2-3 drinks each)

Reservations: Not necessary

📍 Venue Locations & Walking Directions

Hinge match out of my league, step it up

Fancy dinner 🍽️

★★★★★ Ash Nealis

"Stopped by The Bedford on Stone Street and was seriously impressed. I had the Mole Painkiller—a smoky, spiced twist on a..."

The Bedford: Website

Address: 55 Stone St

Happy Hour: No HH

Expected Check: $100-150 (dinner + drinks)

Reservations: Recommended - Resy

Seal the Deal

★★★★★ Patrick Wills

"Wonderful experience at a historic establishment! The place oozes history. There are numerous rooms throughout the build..."

Fraunces Tavern: Website

Address: 54 Pearl St

Happy Hour: 4-7pm Mon-Fri

Expected Check: $60-90 (2-3 drinks each)

Reservations: Recommended - OpenTable

📍 Venue Locations & Walking Directions

Walkable First-Date Flows

Casual Flow: Start at Dead Rabbit (Water St) for Guinness and cocktails → 2-min walk to Stone Street → Stone Street Tavern for post-pub bites → continue down Stone St to Ulysses if you want to keep the night going.
Upscale Flow: Dinner at The Bedford (Stone St) → short walk to Fraunces Tavern (Pearl St) for whiskey and piano bar vibes to seal the deal.
Stone Street Crawl: All the Stone Street spots (Tavern, Bedford, Ulysses) are within 50 feet of each other—perfect for pivoting if a spot doesn't hit.

🔮 FiDi first date vibesSome unexpectedly great date nights have occured in Fidi - the bars are generally less crowded, have some historic charm and plenty of nooks and crannies to slip into. Plus, all the spots are super close together - so no long walks in between destinations. If she lives down here, you can score bonus points by planning something in her hood.

💸 How much will this neighborhood set me back?For a casual night: Start at Dead Rabbit ($50-70) → Stone Street Tavern for bites ($70-90) → Ulysses if you keep going ($40-60). Expect around $160-220 total for a full casual date night. For a fancier vibe: The Bedford dinner ($100-150) → Fraunces Tavern for drinks ($60-90) runs you about $160-240. Bottom line—FiDi has solid options at every price point, and the close proximity means you're not committing to one expensive spot all night.

Date spots to know

Be wary soldier, it's a first date

📍 Venue Locations & Walking Directions

Hinge match out of my league, step it up

📍 Venue Locations & Walking Directions

Walkable First-Date Flows

Sign-up to get weekly date hotspots

Explore Other NYC Date Neighborhoods