Stuytown First Date Ideas

Different part of the city to explore. If she's on the west side, she's not coming here and she'll have to have be BK adjacent, but overall sleeper spots.

Best First-Date Bars in Stuytown

Be wary soldier, it's a first date

Casual first drink 🍸

Motel No Tell: Website

Address: 210 Avenue A

Happy Hour: Mon-Fri from 4pm - 7pm

Expected Check: $50-70 (2 drinks each)

Reservations: Not necessary

Move to light bites? 🥟

Hidden Tiger: Website

Address: 212 Avenue A

Happy Hour: No HH

Expected Check: $70-90 (1 drink/pp + apps)

Reservations: Resy

Ditch 'n Drink 🍺

Otto's Shrunken Head: Website

Address: 538 E 14th St

Happy Hour: No HH

Expected Check: $40-60 (2-3 drinks each)

Reservations: Not necessary

📍 Venue Locations & Walking Directions

Hinge match out of my league, step it up

Fancy dinner 🍽️

Sushi W: Website

Address: 506 E 13th St

Happy Hour: No HH

Expected Check: $184 (2 premium omakase + sake)

Reservations: Required - Resy

Seal the Deal

ReVision Lounge & Gallery: Website

Address: 219 Avenue B

Happy Hour: No HH

Expected Check: $30-$50

Reservations: Recommended - Resy

📍 Venue Locations & Walking Directions

Walkable First-Date Flows

🔮 Stuytown date vibes

Cool spots in an oft-overlooked corner of the city. This is ONLY an option if any of the following conditions apply: she has tattoos, facial piercings, wears baggy jeans, lives in BK/EV or is new to the city. Not the place for that girl off the standouts page on Hinge.

💸 How much will this neighborhood set me back?

Affordable. Sushi W is $68/pp premium omakase w/ sake bottles for $48 but tip is included. You're looking at around $200, but that's omakase for 2 w/ drinks. Bars are definitely cheaper than other neighborhoods, any of the other food options can be pretty cheap.

Sign-up to get weekly date hotspots

Explore Other NYC Date Neighborhoods